Legal challenge against Censor

Monday 17 June 2019 | Published in Entertainment


Legal challenge against Censor
Roger Dunfee watched Rocketman at the Empire Cinema. Now he's mobilising action. 19061606

There is fast- growing concern about Cook Islands moves to ban the movie Rocketman on moral grounds.

A prominent lawyer intends to take a court challenge against the censor’s impending ban of a movie blockbuster about the life of Elton John.

Hundreds of people have already protested online, after Cook Islands News reported this weekend that chief censor Dennis Tangirere intended to ban Rocketman. And one gay community member on the island, Roger Dunfee, is mobilising his friends in California and around the world to overturn the ban.

Te Tiare Association president Regina Potini issued a pointed reminder that the Cook Islands Constitution provides for freedom of speech and expression. “A prohibition of this film/work of art will impinge on this fundamental right guaranteed under the Cook Islands Constitution.”

Yesterday, lawyer Heinz Matysik announced he would challenge the ban, if it proceeded. “If the chief censor wants to roll this way, I will bring a full legal challenge and test the boundaries of our Constitution. I am serious.”

Members of Te Tiare Assocation and the LGBTQ community have spoken out to express their concern, but also with confidence that the sentiments behind the ban are not representative of wider Cook Islands opinion.

* Cooks set to censor Elton

Others, though, have taken to social media in grief or anger.

“Today I question my patriotic pride,” writes Teherenui Koteka. “The fact I belong to a community who in this day and age so outrightly marginalises the LGBTQ community, a community I am proud to be a part of, further illustrates why our country continuously fails to move forward in the modern day world stage.”

“This honestly makes me sad,” says Ally Donnerly. “If my country can't accept a movie then how can they accept me?”

And Brenda says “As a trans woman from Mangaia with a great career in aviation, I find it sad that we are not an evolving nation. More worried about your image in the Pacific than your people.”

The film, a biography of English pop singer Elton John containing intimate gay scenes, had been showing at Empire Cinema for around seven days, but is believed to have been pulled from screening last Friday.

Tangirere spoke to Cook Islands News before the film was pulled, saying her was planning to ban Rocketman because it contained scenes of homosexuality.

The conservative Islamic nation of Egypt had already banned the film, and Samoa followed suit, saying the film did not “go well with the cultural and Christian beliefs of Samoa”.

News of the Cook Islands ban has made overseas headlines, and momentum against the ban is building rapidly.

“This is the wrong message that the Cook Islands wants to be sending the rest of the world” says Roger Dunfee, who postponed a flight to California to mobilise opposition to the ban.

Dunfee, who watched the movie last week, says the ban could have a “detrimental effect” on Cook Islands tourism. “People are likely to just spend their money travelling somewhere else,” he says.

“There are kids now who see this as a complete disapproval of their lifestyle, of what they want to identify as, of who they really are,” he warns. “I know kids who have committed suicide because of these types of issues.”