Jonathan Milne: MPs are all in this together

Monday June 22, 2020 Written by Published in Editorials
Niki Rattle, Speaked of the Cook Islands Parliament, must decide whether to ban a journalist. Niki Rattle, Speaked of the Cook Islands Parliament, must decide whether to ban a journalist.

EDITORIAL: For the past few months, our Parliamentarians have said repeatedly, “we’re all in this together”. Last night, they demonstrated that newfound unity.

But their unanimous vote was not to introduce a new weapon in the fight against Covid-19; it was to condemn Cook Islands News for its reporting on MPs’ travel allowances.

They went further and asked Speaker Niki Rattle to require that Cook Islands News journalist Rashneel Kumar withdraw from reporting Parliament for an (as yet undecided) period.

To be clear: Cook Islands News stands by its reporting of Parliamentary questions about MPs’ entitlement to their spousal travel allowances. Our report was fair, and it was accurate – one need only check back on the recordings of Parliament to recognise that.

* MPs move to ban journalist for travel perks reports
* Payment of MPs’ allowance: You be the judge
* Speaker: MPs working together in the future

Sometimes we will make mistakes, we are human, and if we do we’ll correct them as our Code of Ethics requires. 

We believe this report was accurate.

Yet the front page report of MPs spending Question Time pushing for their allowances to be paid out was also embarrassing for MPs, it seems, and that is why they have come down so hard on the newspaper.

The public can decide for themselves whether the time Parliamentarians have spent defending their allowances is a good use of the House’s scant sitting hours, at a time of national crisis.

What is certain is that the motion to stop our most experienced political journalist reporting on Parliament is an assault on a fundamental democratic right, the freedom of the media – the same right that Prime Minister Henry Puna had paid lip service to just hours earlier.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

1 comment

  • Comment Link Andy Kirkwood Thursday, 25 June 2020 10:26 posted by Andy Kirkwood

    As usual, MPs did no more than read the headline to reach their determination on the content of the article. In a time of device-news, the editor must execute their duties with regard to headlining articles appropriately (according to editorial policy).

    Unless RK penned his own head, the editor must accept responsibility for this situation.

Leave a comment